top of page

A voice from Bethlehem

Nov 4
10 min read

The following post is taken from an interview with my friend Usama Nicola from Bethlehem, recorded in September of this year. You can help support his work and keep up to date on events in Bethlehem by subscribing to his Patreon page HERE


Icon of the Theotokos, Checkpoint 300, Bethlehem
Icon of the Theotokos, Checkpoint 300, Bethlehem

Q: This afternoon I’m with my friend Usama Nicola from Bethlehem - tour guide, peace activist, and a father. So, Usama, tell us a little about yourself and your work in Bethlehem


I’m Usama Nicola from Bethlehem, a peace activist and trainer. I also organise alternative tours to help visitors understand our reality, culture and Palestinian hospitality. We hike in nature, experience the desert and meet different communities. The idea is to help people come, see and understand our daily life.

Q: How long has your family lived in Bethlehem?


My family is originally Bethlehemite. The old city has seven traditional quarters, and I come from Al-Farahiyy, one of the oldest, established around the Church of the Nativity in the late fifth century. We are descendants of the first Christians. Our local church has records of marriages, deaths and baptisms going back at least 800 years. Both my father and mother come from the same clan and quarter.


Q: And your children?


I have three. My eldest is 22 and has just finished university, studying information management systems. He’s looking for work, but unemployment is very high, especially among young people. My daughter has finished high school and plans to study dentistry at Al-Quds University. She dreamed of studying abroad, somewhere safer, but will study locally. Even though the university isn’t far from home, here distance is measured in checkpoints, not kilometres. My youngest son is in tenth grade.


Q: You’ll turn 50 at Christmas. How has Bethlehem changed during your lifetime?


I grew up knowing two realities at once. On one hand, Bethlehem is the town of my faith, family, church, neighbours and friends. It’s beautiful, peaceful and full of history. On the other, there is occupation, restrictions, loss of freedom and injustice. We live with checkpoints, curfews, military presence and settler violence. Just this morning there was settler violence a few minutes from our home, and a military raid in which two people were arrested. These are daily difficulties. Under all this pressure, it’s important for us, as a family and community, to stay human and protect our dignity.


Q: What was it like growing up as a Christian child in Bethlehem?


I was born three minutes from the Church of the Nativity. It was between my home and school, so I passed it every day, often stopping to light a candle or pray. I served at Mass, sometimes twice on Sundays. Christmas was wonderful: parades, scouts, decorations and visitors from around the world. I played the drum in the scouts. We loved going to Manger Square, meeting people, practising English, inviting visitors home and showing them around.


I was born at the end of 1976, so I was about ten when the first Intifada began. I remember coming home from school, seeing what was happening and asking why. Someone explained that people were struggling for their rights, freedom and self-determination. I didn’t understand all those words then. Later, two classmates were killed, one in 1991 and another in 1992. I kept asking: Why are children affected? Children are supposed to be protected. Why can other children go to the Mediterranean while we cannot?


You grow up quickly when you have to ask questions children shouldn’t need to ask. I’ve always told my children to be patient and never lose hope. But they tell me, “You’ve been saying that for a long time, and every day seems worse than the last.”


Q: How do you see the future for your children?


We keep hope alive, but reality is very difficult. Movement is limited, the economy is weak and fear has become normal. Almost 200 Christian families have left Bethlehem. My children ask why we stay instead of going somewhere peaceful and safe, somewhere better for our mental health.

It’s hard to have peace of mind. Even when something doesn’t affect us directly, news of military raids, settler violence or children and women suffering in Gaza affects us. We share that stress. These things must stop. They will never bring peace. Only justice will bring peace. At the moment, we don’t see a clear vision of a better future; we see more fear, anger and racism.


Q: Do you ever consider leaving?


Of course. We discuss it as a family. Leaving might mean better opportunities, healthcare and mental health. But it isn’t easy to leave your home, family and history. Bethlehem is more than a home to me. Being born here is something very special.


Q: You spoke warmly about Christmas as a child. Does Bethlehem still have that atmosphere? Do visitors still come?


Christmas is still joyful, though celebrations and visitor numbers have been reduced. Last Christmas there was a large tree in Manger Square, lights, scouts and some visitors, including Palestinians from other West Bank cities and from inside Israel. Bethlehem opens its doors to everyone. There is room in the inn for everyone.

Christmas brings the message: “Do not be afraid. I’m bringing you good news.” We must receive that joy and grace in our hearts and share it. The season here runs from late November almost to the end of January. I hope more visitors come this year.

When visitors come, we feel we haven’t been forgotten. We want them not only to see holy sites but to meet us, hear our difficulties, hopes and dreams, and discover how similar we are. We share the same human experience, even if our circumstances are different. Meeting people breaks stereotypes. Palestinian hospitality and resilience are remarkable. When we understand each other’s fears and stories, we build bridges rather than walls.



Q: Tell us about the history and significance of the Church of the Nativity.


The first churches were often underground because Christianity wasn’t permitted under Roman rule. The Church of the Nativity was first built in the fourth century, under Constantine and Helena, at the place where Jesus was born. It was later destroyed during the Samaritan revolts and rebuilt on a larger scale by Emperor Justinian in the sixth century. That is substantially the church we have today.


Bethlehem is the capital of Christmas. Sit in the church, read the Christmas story or the parables of Jesus, and reflect. It’s a special spiritual experience. The church remains active and welcomes people, although visitor numbers are low. Restoration has been underway since 2013, including work on the grotto.


At Christmas Eve, my family attends midnight Mass in the grotto, the birthplace of Jesus. There is a large Mass at St Catherine’s, our parish church, with local people, visitors and dignitaries. But we prefer the humble place God chose to appear to us in the flesh. Through Jesus we understand who God is and what God wants from us. The parables, including the Good Samaritan, help us go deeper spiritually.


The Church of the Nativity is shared by different Christian traditions, isn’t it?


Yes. The compound is shared principally by three churches. Through the Door of Humility and the basilica, you reach the Greek Orthodox church. On the right are the Armenian monastery and church; on the left is St Catherine’s, the Roman Catholic church. Syriac Orthodox and Anglicans also hold prayers or celebrations there on certain occasions.


Q: Can you travel from Bethlehem to Jerusalem to visit the Church of the Holy Sepulchre at Easter?


Getting a permit is complicated. Bethlehem and Jerusalem are like twins: one is associated with Christ’s birth, the other with his death and resurrection. Yet West Bank Palestinians need permits to enter Jerusalem. Different Palestinians have different identity documents—Israeli citizenship, East Jerusalem residency, West Bank IDs or Gaza IDs—and different rights of movement. There are many categories of permit, including for work, medical care and family reunification.

At Christmas or Easter, Christians can apply, but there’s no guarantee. Sometimes I get a permit and my wife doesn’t, or one child gets one and another doesn’t. Rarely can all five of us travel together. Some work permits have also been cancelled, including permits for people employed by Christian schools.

I used to walk to Jerusalem from home in about three hours. I belong to Jerusalem as I belong to Bethlehem. Now a wall and checkpoint separate us. Even with a permit, there can be conditions: you may not be allowed to stay overnight or drive. If my cousin from Jerusalem offers me a lift, I cannot simply ride through the checkpoint with him. I must cross on foot and meet him on the other side.

It also affects marriage. Someone with a West Bank ID who marries a Jerusalem resident cannot simply move to Jerusalem, while the Jerusalem resident risks losing residency by moving to Bethlehem. People don’t fall in love according to identity cards. These restrictions are one reason families leave.


Join us on substack for more news from the Holy Land by clicking the image
Join us on substack for more news from the Holy Land by clicking the image

Q: What reasons are given for these restrictions? Israel says the separation wall and checkpoints are security measures, particularly in response to suicide bombings during the second intifada. How do you respond?


The Israeli government justifies the restrictions on security grounds. But the issue isn’t whether someone is Christian, Muslim or Jewish. I believe the wall is an illegal wall of apartheid and segregation. Construction began in 2002, and it remains incomplete. Workers still cross through openings, sometimes facing arrest or death.

The route of the wall takes land from the West Bank. The International Court of Justice addressed its legality in 2004. It has uprooted trees, harmed communities and damaged nature. I don’t encourage violence. For me, resilience and resistance mean remaining present, educating our children and building bridges, not walls. A wall will not create better relationships.


Q: Even by the logic of security, the restrictions seem inconsistent.


Only justice and peace will bring security. Walls will never bring better relationships. Palestinians aren’t going to disappear, and neither are Israelis. We need a common vision based on restorative justice, human rights and respect for humanity. Every child and every woman must be protected. Without justice for Palestinians, there will never be peace.


Q: Do Palestinian Christians have a particular role in building peace?


Palestinian Christians have long played a positive role as a bridge in society. We are part of the Palestinian people, share the same occupation and difficulties, and must share in building a better future. Our Christian presence is small in number but significant in its contribution. Christian institutions provide education, healthcare, services and jobs for the wider community, not only Christians. We stand for justice, an end to occupation, equal rights and democracy.


Q: That contribution is vital, especially when some people want to frame the conflict as a religious war between Christianity, Judaism and Islam.


What’s happening here is not a religious crisis! It is about occupation and injustice. There are Israeli Jews who come to the West Bank to stand against settler violence. So this isn’t about Jew against Christian or Muslim; it’s about justice and injustice. We must unite against injustice. Palestinians and Israelis will continue living here. We need to respect one another, protect dignity, ensure freedom of movement and end the occupation.


Q: What could a peaceful political settlement look like?


The reality is extremely complicated. Palestinian representatives accepted a two-state solution based on the 1967 borders, and some Israelis supported it. Others opposed it, and an Israeli prime minister, Yitzhak Rabin, was assassinated after pursuing a peace agreement. We need brave leaders with a clear vision.

The Palestinian leadership and international community still speak about two states. I don’t know whether that’s still possible. On the ground, I see one state with apartheid, and that apartheid must end. Whatever the political arrangement, there must be a common vision between Palestinian and Israeli leaders based on dignity and restorative justice.


Q: What responsibility do Christians in Britain, Europe and the United States have towards Palestinians in the Holy Land?


First, they must understand the situation and see Palestinians as fully human. Don’t take sides before listening to the Palestinian narrative. There are many narratives, but my reality is that I live under military occupation that violates my dignity and rights.

Christians should understand the Bible as a spiritual guide to what God wants from us, not simply a history book. Jesus stood beside the weak and the victim. We must learn the history, listen to those living under occupation and work for their human rights. Palestinians make mistakes; we aren’t angels. But we are marginalised and living with trauma. We don’t ask people to stand with us uncritically. We ask them to stand for justice.


Q: I’d like to add my own thoughts here - I think Christians in the West also need to understand the importance of presence and encounter. Of coming to the Holy Land, meeting Palestinian and Israelis - Christians, Muslims and Jews and hearing their hopes and fears. And of course supporting local communities through tourism and commerce. Justice and peace are more likely with economic stability.

For example, meeting you has changed my understanding. And I think western Christians also need to understand how their own history of antisemitism and political abuse of religion has contributed to much of the problem.


Yes, if we want a different reality, we must go to the roots. The root isn’t religion; it’s abuse of religion - for colonisation, politics, power, control. Christianity has been misused. If we only address the outcomes without the causes, nothing will change.


We need a culture of respect and honesty. Christianity should never be used to justify colonisation. The Christianity I know teaches us to pray for the whole world, to show mercy to everyone and to love every human being. God loves every person and wants the best for them.


If we stay apart and hate each other, there will be no solution. We need dialogue: to listen, respect one another and be assertive rather than aggressive. Some things people say are real; others are propaganda or exaggeration. But we must remember that we all belong to the same human family.


Q: There’s something you’ve mentioned that comes back to my mind. It’s the Angel’s message at the Annunciation, that was repeated to to the shepherds at Beit Sahour, the message repeated throughout the Bible, both Old and New Testaments - “Do not be afraid… Do not fear.”

Because of what happened in Bethlehem and what happened thirty years later - six miles away in Jerusalem - we should never be afraid. For Christians, the Resurrection should give us the courage to take risks and love, even when doing it is difficult. Because of what happened at the site of the Holy Sepulchre - Christians of all people should never be afraid.

We can live dangerously. We can love dangerously. The game’s already won.

I mean, I know that theoretically… and sometimes that I feel it. When I don’t act on it, it’s because I lack faith - not because the message isn’t true.


I agree. We need to trust God and not be afraid. The truth will set you free.


Q: I think that’s a good place to end. Thank you, Usama.


Thank you for the opportunity. God bless you, and hopefully we will welcome you one day soon in Bethlehem.


Q: Inshallah


Hear from Usama in his own words here:

Help support Usama’s work through his Patreon page
Help support Usama’s work through his Patreon page


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page